9 Comments
User's avatar
Jodie Roberts's avatar

I too remember reading Spark's comment about Sandy, but can't remember where, sorry.

When I went to college in Edinburgh in 1971 my landlady was a Morningside Lady - very nice, but absolutely of the type, tweed-wearing, church-going, and she always had a female student lodger - she threw me out after a term, very nicely, for being disreputable. At college I met a girl who'd been to "Marcia Blaine's Academy" (and had been an extra in the film). She seemed to feel the experience had been lacking Brodie but much the same otherwise.

Expand full comment
E.J. Barnes's avatar

I think she is supposed to have said it at the Edinburgh Book Festival, but I can't remember where I read it.

Thrown out as disreputable by a Morningside Lady! That is a claim to fame! Sounds like a story in itself.

Expand full comment
Jodie Roberts's avatar

I almost wish it had been more of a story - I was really just a slightly rackety 17-year-old who stayed out late and (in those days) smoked. But perhaps she was shrewder about what I smoked than I realised!

Expand full comment
Sarah Harkness's avatar

Such an interesting piece. I've been reading some Spark lately, and it may be time to revisit Brodie. I was fascinated by the reference to the Mitford sisters, I think you're onto something there!

Expand full comment
E.J. Barnes's avatar

It's a compelling read. Which ones have you been reading? I read quite a few but ages ago - A Far Cry from Kensington and The Ballad of Peckham Rye stick in the mind.

Expand full comment
Sarah Harkness's avatar

Far Cry, and The Girls of Slender Means. Loved them both, they aren't like anything else, are they?

Expand full comment
E.J. Barnes's avatar

They are quite odd books for sure, I never feel I quite "get" them - maybe that's the point!

Expand full comment
Part 2 Of Your (Love?) Life's avatar

Liked the comparison of Miss Brodie's group of girls with the Mitford sisters.

Expand full comment
E.J. Barnes's avatar

There's been a lot about the Mitfords lately, so maybe that's why it chimed with me.

Expand full comment